ShmoopTube

Where Monty Python meets your 10th grade teacher.

Search Thousands of Shmoop Videos

Math 5: Critiquing Classmates 10 Views


Share It!


Description:

Unless you want to be a food critic, you should probably know how to give constructive feedback that doesn't leave people feeling dead inside.

Language:
English Language

Transcript

00:00

Critiquing your classmates can be tough on the one hand you want to

00:17

help improve your classmates work on the other hand you don't want to hurt [student at the front of class giving a presentation]

00:20

anyone's feelings and make them leave the room crying luckily we figured out

00:24

some guidelines that will help you give constructive criticism and if you agree

00:28

you can tell us constructively of course so the first part of constructive [a woman giving tips to students sat at a table]

00:33

criticism is to not hold back if you see something that needs revising when

00:37

you're looking over your friends work be sure to take notes on anything that's [a boy meticulously studying another students work on a PC screen]

00:41

incorrect so you can tell them later remember the point of constructive

00:44

criticism is to make the work better so even if it's tough your friend needs to

00:48

hear the things that are wrong a whole bunch of encouraging thumbs up might

00:52

feel good to receive but they're not all that helpful however it's a good idea to

00:56

give a couple of thumbs up just to make sure to point out some of the good

01:00

things that are happening by mixing your criticism with some praise your critique [highlighted good points of another students work]

01:03

is much more likely to be heard and accepted that said if your friend didn't

01:07

actually do any work and just gives you a rock with a bunch of scratches on it

01:10

it'll be hard to find too many good point maybe suggest not too heavy it's [a boy with his arms folded looking upset]

01:14

also very important to offer a suggestion for improvement with each

01:18

critique each time you find a problem with your friends work chances are

01:21

there's going to be a solution out there and if you help to find that solution

01:24

your critique will be incredibly helpful last but not least remember to be kind [Dino pointing to tip #4 on a chalkboard]

01:29

it's hard enough having your work criticized by others and it's even

01:32

harder if the person isn't nice about it put yourself in their shoes and think

01:35

about how you'd feel of you were getting a similar critique oh but don't actually [a boy crying reading a critique of his work]

01:39

put yourself in their shoes you might need to critique the work of people with

01:42

smaller feet than you and you're not helping anyone if you break their shoes

Up Next

ELA 5: How to Spot Bias
3247 Views

Check out the best bias video ever made, courtesy of the most awesome and amazing educational website in existence.

Related Videos

Social Studies 5: Impeachment
1011 Views

No, this isn't a terrible new mint-peach bubble gum flavor...though it does tend to leave a bad taste in people's mouths.

Social Studies 5: Jamestown
335 Views

Those settlers in Jamestown really should have settled down with all that land-stealing. Tobacco's bad for you anyway.

Social Studies 5: The Birth of Canada
199 Views

Being born out of multiple wars doesn't quite seem to fit the peaceful, polite Canadians we know and love today...oh wait, they were called The Bea...

Social Studies 5: How to Analyze a Political Cartoon
636 Views

Not every cartoon is meant to entertain small children while their mother gets some "Mommy time." There are also political cartoons, which are mean...