ShmoopTube
Where Monty Python meets your 10th grade teacher.
Search Thousands of Shmoop Videos
Donne Criticism 286 Views
Share It!
Description:
Critics started attacking Donne's works only after he had passed away. Talk about kicking a guy when he's already down.
Transcript
- 00:01
Donne: Criticism, a la Shmoop. John Donne’s one of those guys who makes
- 00:09
you feel like you’re not doing anything with your own life. Yeah… one of those.
- 00:15
He traveled across Europe and fought against the Spanish.
- 00:19
He was imprisoned for marrying Anne More without her dad's permission.
- 00:23
He transformed himself from a broke lawyer into a prominent preacher.
Full Transcript
- 00:28
And, of course, he wrote poetry. The anonymous editor of a 1633 edition of
- 00:34
Donne's work, published two years after the poet's death, praised his ability to rhyme
- 00:39
the word “dead” with “discovered” and “determined.”
- 00:46
The editor also went on to say that Donne's poetry was the most awesome thing to happen
- 00:50
to English literature ever, never mind that Shakespeare guy.
- 00:54
Other people must have agreed with this assessment, because the poems were reprinted multiple
- 00:59
times during the seventeenth century. Yet, at the same time, a number of critics
- 01:07
and other poets turned against Donne.
- 01:09
The dude was dead; it's not like he could defend himself.
- 01:12
The anti-Donne camp disliked the irregular rhythm and weird imagery of his poetry.
- 01:17
Dryden, an influential seventeenth-century poet who wrote a lot of stuff you've never
- 01:22
heard of, spoke for many when he referred dismissively to Donne's “rough cadence”.
- 01:26
By the time Samuel Johnson was writing his Dictionary of the English Language in the
- 01:34
eighteenth century, Donne was really out of fashion… much like shoulder pads and mullets
- 01:38
are today.
- 01:40
Johnson thought metaphysical poetry like Donne's was interesting, but that it also had some
- 01:44
serious problems. Donne groupies remained scarce on the ground
- 01:49
during the nineteenth century, when free-flowing, sensuous Romantic poetry was what got people
- 01:54
all… hot and bothered.
- 01:59
Who wanted to wrestle with the irony of Donne's poetry when you could read a pretty little
- 02:02
lyrical sonnet about a nightingale instead?
- 02:08
Robert Chambers, a nineteenth-century critic, directed a particularly nasty piece of commentary
- 02:13
at Donne's poems.
- 02:14
They were, in his opinion, “cold and forced conceits, mere vain workings of the intellect.”
- 02:21
Chambers also concluded that the poets of Queen Elizabeth the First's time, like Shakespeare,
- 02:26
could out-sonnet Donne any day of the week. Oh, snap.
- 02:31
Then came the Victorians, a notoriously prudish bunch, who objected to the frank sexuality
- 02:37
in some of Donne's poetry.
- 02:39
Fleas and lovers in bed together? What next? Sheep? Dogs? Smoky the Bear?
- 02:45
It wasn't until the Scottish literary scholar and critic Herbert Grierson edited his collection
- 02:50
of metaphysical poetry in 1912 that Donne's reputation began to revive.
- 02:57
Donne was given an additional boost in 1921, when T.S. Eliot published his essay on metaphysical
- 03:02
poetry.
- 03:04
After that, Donne was well on his way to a spectacular re-evaluation as one of England's
- 03:10
most inventive and formative poets.
- 03:14
In your eye, Robert Chambers.
Up Next
Dr. Seuss was a failure to start, but he soon learned to follow his heart. He wrote books about things that he knew, and soon enough, his book sale...
Related Videos
Sure, Edgar Allan Poe was dark and moody and filled with teenage angst, but what else does he have in common with the Twilight series?
Emily Dickinson was a New England poet/hermit with a fascination with death and immortality. She wrote over 1000 poems in her lifetime, most of the...
